Montezuma, II, Emperor of Mexico

Montezuma, II, Emperor of Mexico

c. 1843
Artist
unknown artist
Engraver
William Greatbach, English, 1802-1894
Born: Stoke-on-Trent, England
Country
United States
Object
engraving
Medium
ink on paper
Accession Number
2000.333
Credit Line
Collection of Frederick and Jan Mayer

William Greatbach, Montezuma II, Emperor of Mexico, after 1843. Engraving; 8 ¼ × 5 ½ in. Gift of the Collection of Frederick and Jan Mayer, 2000.333.

Dimensions
height: 8 1/4 in, 20.9550 cm; width: 5 1/2 in, 13.9700 cm; image height: 4.25 in, 10.7950 cm; image width: 2.938 in, 7.4625 cm; mat height: 20 1/8 in, 51.1175 cm; mat width: 16 1/8 in, 40.9575 cm
Inscription
graphite: top right Mex; printed bottom center Montezuma IInd; Emperor of Mexico Engrav'd by Wm Greatbach From a painting in the Collection of his Descendant the Conde de Miravalle
Department
Mayer Center, Latin American Art
Collection
Latin American Art

Moctezuma II or Moctezuma Xocoyotzin (c. 1466-1520), commonly known as Montezuma, is a contested figure in the historical record. He was the leader (tlatoani) of the Mexica Empire, centered in Tenochtitlan. Under Moctezuma, the Empire reached its greatest size. He was in power when Cortés and his band of soldiers arrived from the Yucatan peninsula in 1519. The conquistador eventually took Moctezuma hostage and he died shortly thereafter.

The inscription at the bottom notes that the engraving is a copy after a portrait of the emperor once in the collection of the Conde de Miravalle, a noble title established in 1690 for Alonso Dávalos Bracamontes de Ulibarri y de la Cueva, who was directly descended from both Philip II and the daughter of Moctezuma II. As was common with noble families in the Spanish Americas, the Condes de Miravalle commissioned this fictional portrait of their ancestor to strengthen their claim to royal descent. Sometime in the 1800s, the portrait was sold to the former United States consul in Mexico, Santiago Smith Wilcox, who brought the original to the US and had it engraved.

The engraving was included as the frontispiece to William H. Prescott’s History of the Conquest of Mexico, first published in 1843 but reprinted several times throughout the second half of the 1800s. It was not original to the work but was secured by Prescott’s agents in Mexico and re-engraved in London by William Greatbach. Prescott was initially adamant that the portrait was authentic, particularly in its depiction of Moctezuma’s robes, but later came to believe that it was too idealized a depiction. As other historians have noted, the costume takes greater cues from Roman garments such as the paludamentum than from Mexica royal regalia.

Moctezuma is depicted with considerable pathos, his head declined slightly with a vacant, sorrowful gaze. One reader of Prescott’s text described the engraving of Moctezuma thusly: “poor wretched, doomed, self-doomed monarch, such as his portrait speaks him.” This attitude was a common one, as many historical texts depicted the Mexica leader as tragic, superstitious, and weak. The popularity of Prescott’s text, a sweeping, literary account of the Conquest, meant that this image circulated widely in the second half of the 1800s.

– Kathryn Santner, Frederick and Jan Mayer Fellow of Spanish Colonial Art, 2022

Some images in our online collection are at thumbnail size, in accordance with AAMD guidelines, because they are protected by copyright. The Denver Art Museum respects the rights of artists or their representatives who retain the copyright to their work. Other images represent the best photography available and should be used as reference images only. Please complete the Image Rights Request form if you want to request a high resolution image.